Rethinking Mathematics: Teaching Social Justice by the Numbers is
an anathema, not only to traditional education, it is blatantly
brainwashing minds with politically correct calculations. From coast to
coast, classrooms are prepping children for community activism.
From the Northwest Teachers for Social Justice http://nwtsj.org/ to New York City’s El Puente Academy for Peace and Justice http://insideschools.org/high/browse/school/657,
a mission in formulating a unique standard in teaching mathematics is
rapidly being reinforced in our schools. ‘Social justice’ epithets are
pervasive in education reform, resonating a compassion for the under
privileged and seeking to change the inequities in communities. Radical
educators are not satisfied however with using the Social Sciences to
waken minds to the injustices of the world. The new equation is adding
critical theory to mathematics instruction. One only needs to read the
table of contents of the above to foresee the bar graph of oppressed
minority children rise, due to lack of an academic education; Driving
While Black or Brown, Sweatshop Accounting, Justice for Janitors,
Chicanos Have Math in Their Blood, steer a course in “teaching
mathematics for Racial Justice.
Ethnocmathematics combines math with anthropology, and proponents seek
to even relegate it to a relativistic philosophy for the future. Since
Paulo Freire’s Pedagogy for the Oppressed was published in 1970, a
Critical Pedagogy developed for exploration in linking the classroom to
sociopolitical issues. For the present, we need look no deeper than the
various web vendors selling peace, and prosperity.
Teachingforchange.org markets ‘Putting the Movement Back in Civil Rights
Teaching’ a resource digressing to the sixties. It is listed in
Rethinking Mathematics and is underscored by a raving review given by
Linda Darling-Hammond, a member of the Validation Team for the Common
Core.
Lessons on learning statistics and probability as early as the 2nd
grade is a prerequisite for gathering and interpreting data and creating
graphs for a comparison of a host of local and global problems.
Advocates for teaching math for social justice (SJM) take advantage of
the American Statics Association’s work on the skills related to this
branch of mathematics. Contributors creating the “Guidelines for
Assessment and Instruction in Statistics Education” (GAISE) have issued a
report on recommendations for statistics education for grades K-12.
GAISE examples cited for data gathering are non-sociopolitical.
Ethnomathematics, however, would propose controversial topics inclusive
of racial profiling, environmental racism, pollution, poverty, conflict
and economic disparities. Lessons in this resource perfectly fit with
the social, economic and environmental strands in the ‘sustainable
standards’ posted at the US Partnership. http://s3.amazonaws.com/usp_site_uploads/resources/123/USP_EFS_standards_V3_10_09.pdf
Corporations and ‘social justice’ advocates make strange bedfellows, but that is the mix for communitarianism.
The ‘City Journal’ reported on a three day conference held in New York
City, “Creating Balance in an Unjust World: Math Education and Social
Justice”. Jonathan Osler, a math teacher at EL Puente Academy won a
grant from the Zone Teacher Inquiry Grants Program funded by the NYC’s
Department of Education to host the event. An article, in the City
Journal, added the Mayor’s tolerance of ‘leftist politics in the
classroom’, which contrast with his support of corporate led changes in
restructuring schools. “El Puente was founded with funding from
uber-capitalist Bill Gate’s education foundation”. http://www.city-journal.org/html/eon2007-03-19ss.html There’s the social injustice, the elite helping the underclass underachieve.
James Milgram, the only mathematics academic on the Common Core
Validation Team, chose not to endorse the standards. “We’ve added data
analysis, statistics, and aspects of the “new math” including problem
solving, Euclidian transformations and simple combinatorics since I was
young. And our outcomes keep getting worse”. Milgram warns Americans
that technical jobs in the future require a thorough ground in
mathematics from an early age. His articles are most revealing on
knowing the difference between teaching numbers on the value they
represent, rather than an exercise in vocabulary. http://math.stanford.edu/milgram/education-index.html
Ethnomathematics, aka critical mathematics, is a pointless effort
without critical thinking skills. Critical pedagogy is dialogical and
dialectical materialism is the science of Marxism, seeking social
justice through the collective. Ethnomathematics targets ethnic groups
and justifies a victim mentality in children. It segregates ethnic
minorities from traditional sequential mathematic instruction needed in
post-secondary opportunities. SJM is a radical, racially biased method
of unlearning pure academics. Teaching math for social justice is not a
‘fuzzy math’ trend. It’s not going to be erased easily.